Mr Garfield Dunlop (Simcoe North):
My question today is for the Minister of Community
Safety and Correctional Services. Minister,
yesterday you announced that you will act to
install video cameras in police cruisers as
recommended in the racial profiling report by
the Ontario Human Rights Commission. Please
inform the House how much this program will
cost the taxpayers, both as a pilot in this
fiscal year and upon full implementation. How
will it impact the so-called election promise
to hire 1,000 new police officers across our
province?
Hon Monte Kwinter (Minister of Community
Safety and Correctional Services):
I thank the member for the question. I find
it strange that you're asking me that question.
You should be addressing that question to the
former minister, because this was an initiative
of your government. This is something that you
initiated. I should tell you that, at the present
time, this pilot project will provide cameras
in OPP vehicles, 12 of them up in Kenora, 22
in the Toronto area and two for research and
development. This has nothing to do with the
commitment we have made to put 1,000 new police
officers into the police services across Ontario
during this mandate.
You should know that today Brian Adkin, the
president of the OPPA, issued a press release
saying that he supports this. He thinks this
is great. You should also know that the RCMP
have 400 video cameras, and they've had them
for eight years. The military police in Canada
have had them for three years. Peel, Durham,
the Quebec Provincial Police are all looking
at putting in video cameras.
Mr Dunlop: Minister, our caucus
believes that the only reasons video cameras
should ever be installed in police cruisers
would be for the safety of police officers and
for investigative purposes -- we do agree with
Mr Runciman on that -- not as a Big Brother
tactic for spying on our officers. Any other
reason would show a complete lack of trust and
discrimination against the very people who allow
Ontarians to live in a safe, civil and secure
society.
Minister, your announcement immediately following
the recommendations of the commission clearly
shows that you want video cameras installed
in police cruisers for discriminatory and spy
tactic reasons. Do you trust the police officers
of Ontario to do their jobs, or do you not trust
the police officers to do their jobs?
Hon Mr Kwinter: I totally reject
the assumptions you have made. I should quote
from OPPA Brian Adkin's press release, in which
he says, "OPPA supports cameras in police
cruises to allow for monitoring the interaction
between police and the public." That is
the purpose. That was an initiative that we
had in the works. The only reason why it came
to light yesterday is because there was a recommendation
in Commissioner Norton's report saying we should
do it. All I was confirming is that we are doing
it. There is no motivation other than that.
This is an initiative that, as I said before,
began in your administration. We are carrying
it forward. It is a good police tool, and I
can assure you that it will serve the people
of Ontario well.