Mr.
Garfield Dunlop (Simcoe North): My question
today is for the Minister of Community Safety
and Correctional Services. Minister, according
to the PAO today, it's quite obvious that we're
in desperate need of police resources. You're
now 26 months into your mandate, and there are
a lot of communities desperately looking for assistance
under the 1,000 cop program.
The city of Barrie, as you know, is one of the
fastest-growing communities per capita in our
province. Chief Wayne Frechette and the Barrie
Police Services Board are responsible for the
safety of the citizens of this very rapidly growing
city. The city has applied for 34 net new officers
under your Safer Communities-1,000 Officers Partnership
program.
Minister, can you assure us, to the best of your
ability, that the city of Barrie will receive
the approval and funding they need for those 34
officers that they have very, very faithfully
applied for?
Hon. Monte Kwinter (Minister of Community
Safety and Correctional Services):
I think the member should understand that when
we put out the call for these officers, we got
considerably more responses than the 1,000 officers
we have committed to. What we have to do is
evaluate them, (a) to find out if they meet
our criteria, and (b) to find out if in fact
we have them available.
You should know that what we have done is very
significant. Your government's community policing
programming was supposed to lapse in five years.
We have not only extended that, we've extended
it in perpetuity. By the time we are finished
with this program, we will have provided $67.1
million a year in perpetuity.
Now, whether Barrie, Ottawa or any other community
is going to get what they ask for, I think it
would be unrealistic because there aren't enough
police officers to go around. But we will apportion
them fairly and transparently and make sure
that every police service is dealt with in a
fair and upright manner.
Mr. Dunlop: They wouldn't
have applied for them if they didn't need them.
That's the problem.
We've learned that the region of York, under
the leadership of Chief Armand La Barge, who
is also the president of the Ontario Association
of Chiefs of Police, and the police services
board in York region have applied for the most
in the province. They've applied for 148 community
policing officers and 143 of the specific program
officers under your 1,000 cop announcement.
Minister, of the 291 net new officers -- and
that's, of course, more than even the city of
Toronto applied for -- 160 of those would fall
into the retroactive hiring practice. The question
really is more on funding now. When can York
region expect to see their application for the
291 new officers approved, but, more importantly,
when will they actually receive funding or get
their cheque for the 160 officers that they
have retroactively hired since October 2003?
Hon. Mr. Kwinter: I'm sure
the member knows how the process works. What
has happened is that various police services
-- and I have to stress that funding of police
officers is a metro or a municipal responsibility.
What we are doing is helping them out with this
program, as you did when you were in government
with your community policing program. So it
isn't our responsibility to fund all the policing
in Ontario. What we have done is that we want
to help those municipalities that don't have
the fiscal capability of doing it. So we are
doing that, and we are going to be providing
that funding.
Also, I'm sure you know, because it's exactly
the same process you used, all of this funding
is done in arrears. We have to make sure that
these people were actually hired and that they
meet our criteria. They then bill us for their
share, and we pay them in arrears. That's the
way it was done before; that is the way it's
going to be done now.
The Speaker (Hon. Michael A. Brown):
New question.
Mr. Howard Hampton (Kenora-Rainy River):
My question is for the Acting Premier. Yesterday
yet another Ontario citizen was shot on the
street, the latest victim of a rising wave of
gun violence. Ontario citizens are afraid. Eighty
per cent of Ontarians feel that gun violence
is a growing problem. But what do they see?
They see a McGuinty government that is apparently
more concerned with banning pit bulls than addressing
the crisis of gun violence.
My question is this: Can you explain why the
number of police officers on our streets, measured
on a per capita basis, is declining under the
McGuinty government?
Hon. Gerard Kennedy (Minister of Education):
The Attorney General.
Hon. Michael Bryant (Attorney General):
I'm happy, in a supplementary, to provide more
information for the Minister of Community Safety
and Correctional Services. But let's be clear:
Notwithstanding anything that was just said,
this government is investing more money in police
services than that government ever invested
in police services. This government is putting
into place 1,000 new police officers. They made
the promise to do it; we're doing it. Make no
mistake about it: The investments that are going
into public safety, policing and prosecutors,
doing everything we can to prevent violence,
are in fact at a level that puts public safety
first. The suggestion that anybody in this House
thinks that somehow dogs are more important
than the 44 dead Torontonians, than the 70 people
shot, is absolutely outrageous. And you should
be --
The Speaker: Thank you. Supplementary.
Mr. Hampton: People have heard
the McGuinty government announce, reannounce
and reannounce again more police officers, but
they don't see it happening.
I want to quote someone who said this two years
ago: "The number of police officers per
capita in Ontario has dropped more than 8% in
the past 10 years. We need more police officers
to keep our communities safe." Who said
that? Dalton McGuinty.
What has happened after two years of the McGuinty
government? Measured on a per capita basis,
the number of police officers on the street
is now down by 9%. You're not keeping pace,
not even with the Conservatives.
Now municipalities are saying they are cash-strapped.
You force them to pay two thirds of the cost
of new police officers while you pay only one
third of the cost. Will the Acting Premier guarantee
cash-strapped municipalities today that if they
cannot pick up the full two thirds of the cost
that you demand, they will still get new police
officers under the McGuinty government?
Hon. Mr. Bryant: The Minister
of Community Safety and Correctional Services.
I just want to bring to the attention of the
leader of the third party that between 1990
and 1995, based on police officers per 100,000,
the NDP government decreased the number of police
officers by 5.246%.
Hon. Mr. Kwinter: I can tell
you that in 1990 the NDP had 20,685 police in
Ontario; in 2004, the year we were in government,
23,214. Those are the numbers, and I challenge
you to challenge those numbers.
Interjections.
The Speaker: Order. Stop the
clock.
New question.